SRK is no stranger to being in the limelight, but it seems that sometimes he is talked about for all the wrong reasons. Rumors have been circulating that in a recent magazine interview, SRK compared the Prophet Mohammad to negative figures in history, such as Hitler. Obviously, these comments have offended many people in the Muslim community.
According to the rumors, the Mumbai Aman Committee has issued a complaint against Shahrukh Khan to the Bandra Police Station. They claim that SRK has offended the attitudes of their community and a clarification from the actor is in order.
According to reports, the interview, which was printed in "Time'n Style Luxury" magazine, reads as follows:
"According to you who is the most impressive figure in history?
'There are lots of them, some negative ones like Hitler, then Napoleon, Winston Churchill and if I can call it history, then Prophet Mohammed and from recent time - Nelson Mandela. And there are the nice ones like Gandhiji and Mother Teresa.'"
However, in an attempt to cover their tracks, the magazine published a clarification of the interview in a tabloid. The Magazine claims that the answer to the question should have appeared in the following way:
''There are lots of them, some negative ones like Hitler. Then Napoleon, Winston Churchill were impressive. If I can call it history, then most impressive positive figure is Prophet Mohammad. And from recent time - there are nice ones like Nelson Mandela, Gandhiji and Mother Teresa''.
Let us know what you think of this controversy. Has SRK dug himself into yet another hole, or was this simply a magazine faux pas??
Want to comment on this article? [ Sign in ] or [ get a FREE account ] at Desi Hits! (You get access to free MP3s and other stuff, too).
EXCUSE ME Party.. whtever i dnt reli give a shit u dnt no anything abt islam so tht meanz u aint fuckin have to say a word and u aint got anyfin to do wiv our prophet (pbuh)and u tell us when you find out there is judgement day tht wud be the happiest day of my life when judgement day cums ill remember u first and poor u rotting in hell u will be worst thn u are at the moment and if sharukh khan did say tht may he rot in hell and allah will give u more punishment thn he will giv to srk INSHALLAH I PRAY TO GOD MAY U DIE (becoz u no there is allah)ONE AND ONLI and btw ramesh_sean i no ur takin our side and all but plz allah is allah in all languages u may call other so called god ishwarr baguhan and all tht but ALLAH IS ALLAH IN ALL LANGUAGES
Hi every one. I'm ramesh a desi british. I saw all this post and I'm thinking 'partybhai' name sounds like desi & he is a hindu. In hindu scriptures also it says that there is one 'GOD' in hindi 'Ishwar', so the muslim people who said about this is true! Ishwar in arabic 'ALLAH' in english 'GOD' in hindi 'Ishwar' in bengali 'Khuda'. And you partybhai said that there is no 'GOD' means 'ALLAH'. You must not be a true Hindu as far as I can see, You do not belivein Ishwar! I'm asking you one question ARE YOU A HUMAN FIRST or A HINDU FIRST?
Time will come!
felt bad even v feel bad...this was just to make u realize how it feels...got it!!!if u can speak bad they r pll wo can give u nice in ur language...
if u speaking soo ill abt our religion den wat is ur saalo tum log to luarde ko bhi puujte ho shivling bolke sslo tumlog ke to bhagwaan bhi marte hai ek book nahi hai tumlogo ki haa...in one book of ur to even animal fools ur god lolzzzzzzzzz...waat hai religion ke naam pe...hahahhahha...jhaat ke jinge maine ye sab pada nahi tha phela comment likhne se phele waarna sidhii hi lagaa deti hijhrde to tumlogo me hi paida hote hai mahabharaat ke tym se lolz..gaand maari ke...jaa maa chuda apni..
mr partybhai........islam speaks about many things that is discovered now by the scientist...do u ur self follow ur religion properly... answer will b no..speaking ill abt others religion u show wat value u hav got...even ur ghandiji which we consider our baapu has said prophet is d noblest man ever existed so...mr before commenting on others religion plzz get all d info abt it not half or very little...if dat d case even i say many thing abt ur religion but ur ignorent...and am not....wat to argue plzz c dr zakir naik'debate ull get every thing ant it on youtube....
partybhai stop mking bad comments. i am an indian i think saying bad words about other peoples religon. also why are saying bad words about islam only their other religons, chirstianity and others. why only islam. it a good religion and i respect it. even hinduism is good and christian is good and all are good. every religion has different way of reaching god and praying. we just do it differently and beleive in different ways. in every religion it mentions something about other religions aswell. i read the interview with shah ruk khan and he said it was a typing error and has asked for apology. i am glad that he has done as if shah ruk khan is muslim and wants to teach his children about 2 religions then why would he say something like that.
unfaithfullness lolz ur prophet had 30 wives muthfuckas u pigs disrespect women to the max n like hes gona face consequences lolz be realistic u die for the almighty for 72 virgins man thas a slick idea any young guy in his teens would fall for it anyday
People please I have read all your comments, firstly not you the media or anyone else for that matter passes jugement on SRK. There is a supreme...higher power to do that. Lets not forget that the media always like to publish everything else other than the truth especially when u famous..i mean c'mon we have never heard of his unfaithfullness to his wife..why now will he speak ill of our beloved Prophet(peace be upon him)...however if he did he will sure face the consequences. SO lets leave that for the almighty to decide.
i aint sick am jus helping u brainwashed desi muslims to reconvert or lose that faith cuz its fake and made up tell me do u follow the people of the ROTI or the people of the halali pork doesnt matter wat the book says the people speak for themselves look at the hindu/buddha majority counties whos living a better life
after going through all the commentz i just had to sign up to leave a comment cause man this guy partybhai or wateva he is sick...lol.. all ur asking us muslims is for a proof...well to be honest just look around ur self... just look around urself ull and think who made this everything into being...think about how can human beings bring life to anything ... science cannot figure that out neither can they figure out HOW THE FUCK THE BABY IN THE WOMB OF A MOTHER DEVELOPS... itz Allah who does all this... hindus have a lot of gods as i have heard but ive also heard that this is "ishwar" or whatever right and thatz one so thatz Allah,.., even christianz say god and the mean Allah... just a different name is different religions... in the bible it was already said that a prophet would follow after Jesus( may Allah bless him) and even his name was mentioned that waz Ahmed...all the signs were given before... man all i can say is to u ur religion to us ours...and that noone can be forced to convert to any religion they are just given proof of the religion being right... just go and do some research and then come and tawk ok...dont just blabber around... and may Allah guide SRK the right way that is all i can say...
fast of all when ur talking about our prophet mohamed u should say may peace be upon him secondly i dont know if those rumors ur talking about a thruth and if so mr SRK will pay 4 what he says and for all those people out there u should know there`s nothing to compare wit our beloved prophet mohamed may peace be upon him..ALLAHU AKBAR
I am Russian and i envy you because you have Shahrukh. i am not going to scream like a crazy fan "i love him" but i believe you are somehow hard on him .Whatever he said , he meant well.Why not read the man's eyes instead of trapping him by what he says . We all slip mistakes ,being in a public eye and when we work non-stop. Shahrukh, take a deep breath and never mind . To overbalance critics against you i can say that we in Russia love you . You bring togeter with you much more than mere actor talent, you radiate kindness and life .For all others i've got a request:Don't bite the man who has always shared his heart with you .
What r u saying? Partybahia! 1St am a girl n also th hindu ppl call their chldrn by their gods! Have u ever thought who creatd ths huge universe no1 can n no1 wil b able 2. By th way who change into islam r entering into a new faith n believe in Allah! U knw take my word read th Quran! Then in what u believe? R u a hindu or chirstian? How do u live? We were all sent 2 ths world ths world is an examination 4 us, we must go by th Allah's rules.. Coz they r rite. U knw we cant drink it z forbidn also pig's meat look how great is our religion both hurt human's health. And hindu is nt a religion, islam is chirstianity is jeu is. So belive me ourz is the best! Wat r u trying 2 do? Make us change our religion. U r dreaming!
mr black soul ah i forgot i got no issues with other muslims my main focus was on desi MUSLIMS who were CONVERTED i got enuff muslims pepz who are african/middle east they all hate the indian/pakistan muslims but they respect hindus cuz AMITABH bachan IS THERE HERO SO I'LL i wont diss ur relgion but as for rtonsila ur lips n ur moms mouth must smell of an arabs lund in its stench u cant get rid of cuz ur mom sucked it i bet ur last name is EITHER AHMED,SYED, etc CUZ THAS THE NAME OF THE GUY UR MOM BLOWED
its so obvious , you can tell him a Muslim , after you watch his documentary " Inner world of Shahrukh Khan" , busy in idle worshiping. so i think he must have said in that interview, FUCK SHAHRUKH KHAN AND HIS MOVIES AND HIS FANS TOO.
first of all i wanna tell u sth partybhai i'm nt indian ok but i'm a musllim, u have no rite to insult our religion! we have in Allah in our prophet, if u read our Quran then u'll relize how strong our religion is we dnt need proof coz we Allah n we believe in him... hindu pray to these stones as if it z thier god do seriously think that these stones or statues do sth for them nothinggggggggggg ok it doesnt move it z nthng i dnt knw how they believe in such thng no offence also all the other prophets moses jeuses they were sent by our Allah to tell every1 there is one God n no one else but they were misunderstood.... read the Quran this is a mircle no poet no arab can write such thing... do u believe this universe was made by jeuses our these stones that some ppl pray to n believe in no way it z all in our Allah's hand he is the strongest most mercyfullllllllllll understood don't u dare ever again insult islamic religion!!! dnt think no1 will answer u coz every1 did.. n shamuz we dnt kill each other Allah will punish him at the end dnt make a sin ok...
this is for party bhai.. maa lun zyada putt putt na kar ye jo bakwaas kar raha hai teri ass mein ghuss k phatoon ga u dirty indian. ive heard that u drink cowpiss in ur religion MF thats ur standard. and for u shamuz im with u just take his address n let me know cuz ill go with u to fuk him bad. this good for nuthing hindu maaderchod is gona get nothing out of it infact his own kids will burn him to fucking ashes n when he wakes up he'l find out wat fucking deep shit he has got himself into but it would be too late for that..
U partybhai i dont wanna say any bad thing to u but i'm warning u if u say any thing bad or disgrace ALLAH or our prophet i'll kill u!! if u r such cowboy give me ur full address i'll destroy u nd will let the whole world c what happens when sm1 disgrace lyk this..!!!
hindus or people of the VEDIC culture came way b4 islam islam is made by a man who claimed he met god n etc etc u guys have a vedic(hindu) sense of mentality becuz we belive in education/learning / sanskars(values) gulmina and anjum u guys clearly have it becuz u didnt diss me in a bad way as i did but thas becuz ur desi muslim u guys have that hindustani mentality but the problem is u guys are converted n u are inside a box u must get out of the box becuz u were born into islam n were taught to always follow it u guys cant think out of the box meaning all this allah n prohpet is true to u no matter wat proof u have its hard to change pepz i mean i have no issues with pepz like u but i jus want pepz to realize belive in urself n not this allah or prophet stuff that u guys are brainwashed into it in islam the men get the upperhand n more freedom then u ever wil i jus want u women to teach ur kids to never get into islam so they dunt become narrow headed that way wen they grow up they realize the truth is outside the box when i mean box i mean outside ur mind
FOR ANJUM AND MAHAM.....pleaz every 1......just leave it!!!cz ALLAH(THE GR8) WILL TELL EVERY 1ON THE EXACT TIME LEAVE THEM ON ALLAH.DONT CARE WHAT EVER THEY SAY(PARTY BAI AND SRK)...WE DONT NEED TO ABUSE THEM THEY WILL ANSWER FOR THERE ACTS AND ALL ON THE DAY OF JUGEMENT..WE SHUD WORY ABOUT OUR SELVES.. CZ IN QURAN ALLAH HAS MENTIONED DAT EVERY 1 HAS TO ANSWER FOR THER ACTS AND ALL.....U NOE I AM FEELING SORRY FOR SRK PARTY BHAI AND ALL NON MUSLIMS..AND YA!MY MUSLIMS PLEAZ NEVER EVER TRY TO ABUSE SOM1Z GOD AND ALL CZ ALLAH DONT LIKES DAT...BYE PLEAZ DONT ANSER THEM ALLAH WILL SEE THEM INSHALLAH...
PARTY BHAI SUCKING DICK OF SRK IN HELL.
I don't believe ShahRukh was comparing the prophet (SAW) to Hitler. He was merely saying that there are many historical figures and besides, there's a comma and a 'then' after Winston Churchill meaning that he was saying that Prophet Muhammad was a good man in history. Notice that he said and from recent times there are Gandhiji, and Mother Theresa and Nelson Mandela. The three people above didn't live durin the time of the prphet so he can't classify them togethr. You have to look at this very logically and analyze every word in the statement to get what he meant. ShahRukh is a muslim in case you didn't know and muslims never criticize or say bad things about their prphet or religion.
I think his comments are being blown way out of proportion he merely was mentioning impressive history figures - some bad people can be described as impressive (such as Hitler due to how he managed to brainwash so many people through propaganda) - he mentioned Nelson Mandela, Gandhi and Mother Teresa too - so why aren't kaleh and indians going on in an uproar like many muslims are? I dont get it? Chill out and stop mis-reading his comment...
Mr. Parti Bhai ... Mind ur language befor you post a comment like below you should think that you are showing your mentality about the other religions .... is it ever been recorded that any Muslim insults the Personalities of the Hindu Religion ... I think not ... If we Muslim can not to insults the Personalities of any of the religion of the world then nobody (like SRK) who mentioned himself that at morning he prays in front of Bhagwan ... then how could we muslim recognize him to be a Muslim ... we are not hating him ... we are hating what he said about our Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) ... and let me ask you I think you arer a follower of a Hindu Religion ... Have you ever red the scriptures of your religion ... I am Sure abot it " Never " if so ... then you never show your mentality about our Beloved Prophet because ... it is mentioned in Many Hindu Scriptures That the Final Messenger of GOD will come .... and you've pointed that if he was so good then why don't people following him on earth .... I want to ask you that SRK is offering Prayers sometimes ... then according to you (an amazing Actor & a good human being) Have you ever follow such activity of SRK once in whole life ... Definitely you've NEVER FOLLOW him ... know why ???? because every HUMAN has got his/her own mentality & approach ... if you cannot follow the SRK ... then why you blaming the whole human being not to follow our HOLLY PROPHET .....they've their own approach or mentality .... SO STOP TALKING LIKE THIS ... WE MUSLIMS OF THE WHOLE WORLD CONDEMN IT HARDLY ... AND SRK YOU SHOULD FEEL SORRY ON WHAT IS HAPPENED AFTER YOUR COMMENT ..... BEING A (SO CALLED) MUSLIM YOU DIDN'T HAVE ANY RIGHT TO COMPARE OUR BELOVED PROPHET FOR ANY CATEGORY ANY PERSONALITY OR ANYTHING ELSE ....
partybhai shut your mouth rascal other wise i am gonna fuck you,and SRK was not suppose to compare our HOLY Prophet with Hitler he does not have any rights,do you know hitler is responsible for the murder of 60 million people and he compared with him naozubillah..dont say like that ,,,
STOP HATING ON SRK u STUPID HALALI PIGS!!! SRK WILL BE A BIGGER PERSON THEN UR SO CALLED PROPHET WILL EVER BE DO U CONVERTED BRAINWASHED RETARDS HAVE ANY SLIGHT IDEA wat mohamed was or u just heard that he was soo good if he was so holy n godly then why isnt all of earth following him fuckin idoits arguing over srk THE GUYS AN AMAZING ACTOR and a good HUMAN BEING
SRK u rascal if u cant act like a true muslim than u dont have any right to hurt muslim n say sorry to all muslims but u will be never same again n this fame here is nothin.
SRK u rascal if u cant act like a true muslim than u dont have any right to hurt muslim n say sorry to all muslims but u will be never same again n this fame here is nothin.
shut ur f**king mouth (partybhai) it stinks a lot..... Some one Get this Idiot Partybhai cunt out of the Conversation.... Desi Hits Team. dont bark unless u know something, u hav no right 2 criticize or force anyone k
I TAKE THAT BACK > actually it if desi muslims jus acted calm n kool then i have no problem with them converting or non converting only a certain percent of desi muslims get ignorant over such issues like this
mahumj wat will u do wen u find out there no such thing as allah or judgement day n it was just a hoax made by an arab who jus lied to people that GOD ACTUALLy came to him MAN U muslims need to grow up THERES NO SUCH THING AS HELL thank GOD(karma) only a small percent of desis are converted muslims i hope 1 day all ur desis RE-CONVERT BACK TO HINDUISM then we can wash away the smell of camel urine off ur lips
srk u have to pay for it nd u must pay it nd u'll pay for this inshaallah nd 1 more thing what will u do when the judgment day comes nd when u stand in front of Allah every 1 now that there is a day of judgment on the 7th sky then what will u do srk
srk u doesn't have any rights to say any weird thing about HAZRAT MUHAMMAD (s.a.w) u all khans r just pretending like u r a Muslim no! but i think that u all r non-Muslims get lost u all get lost nd go to hell specially srk
this is disgusting srk has to b just shooted out 4m dis world he is a Muslim but he is reacting like a non-Muslim even i m a Muslim that y now i hate srk very much he'll get his punishments in his future nd when the judgment day come every one gets every thing, one day get it , nd that day will come soon
This is not suppose to be a site for religious debate. Just like Hollywood actors, Bollywood tries to stir up a little controversy. Its a way for them to keep the actors alive and in the media. It doesnt take a genius to figure out that this is all part of the drama to get people talking about bollywood. Check it out yourselves and see what you have said. Bollywood just duped you into their world!
GO TO HELL SHAHRUKH AND ROT THERE
XEXO did u feel sad wen ur mom blowed an arabic camels lund to convert to islam n be a wannabe be arab SANAJAAN SRK N SALMAN are both very good people they respect n follow some hindu tradtions but they cant just leave islam in the shadows becuz ur men would try to hurt them n then we cant make bollywood that big in the middle east cuz they get some money off those countries but funny wen the arabs converted ur weak ancestors they forget to teach u how to get married hence why all desi muslims still follow some hindustani traditions its like no matter how many times u bend over each day u still got that hindustani stain creeping up on you no offence to the good muslim pepz i am just saying anything just follow karma
desihits is a site for the latest in movies, music, gossip...not one for religious debate. I am sure there staff is very tolerant of Muslims and may even have Muslims on their team/in their company. SRK isnt the only Muslim...salman khan, aysha takia, imran khan (singer), bonafide, Muslims come from all around the south asian subcontinent, They can be equally indian if they choose to follow Islam. Like i said...religion and culture are 2 diff aspects. dont mix em! the expert on islam is you 'partybhai' you aint even Muslim, prolly neva read the Quran. respect everyone for their faith and dont be hating on all those who are tolerant
hey u Mr. YahooArsh who do u think u r???????? dont pretend to be such a nice muslim as in Islam u dnt have the rit to insult ur neighbour look wat u r b4 taking the name of my SRK he's far a BETTER PERSON than u all JUST WISH TO TELL U SHAH RUKH THAT I LOVE U LOTS
Some one Get this Idiot Party bhai out of the Conversation.... Desi Hits Team , where are you ?
A whole lot of media bull shit. They have nothing better to do that creat sansani khez khabar khamokhan mein kisiko to arram aur chain se baithne do saalon
sharukh khan ek nehaet bakwas actor hai........ wo apne aap ko bht samajta hai........ aur wo apne aap ko mualim kehta hai????? kahan se wo muslim hai.........i am a muslim girl aur u all muslims know that sharukh khan ne khud allahSWT nd aapPBUH ki nawsubillah nafarmani aur shirk keya hai........ in sab batoo ke bad mei to nhi samaj ti k SHARUKH KHAN muslim hai aur ye harkat is ne 2 films mei ki hai. AFTER ALL ALL MUSLIMS SAID THAT HE IS NOT A MUSLIM HE IS COMPLETLY HINDUUUUUU........
being muslim doesnt mean you speak arabic, "eat" arabic. Being Muslim and the way you practice your faith is between oneself and God, partybhai...are you saying all those who are not arabic cannot be muslim? Ima paki Muslim, eat halal, and do not wear tanks and shorts. I am a Muslim and yes somewhere a member of my family has converted to this faith. Being arabic has nothing to do with Islam, dont mix faith/religion and culture. as for srk, i feel he has been misquoted. i hope that ppl simmer down about this
u said the most prestigious person on earth lolz u met him or ever knew him have an solid proof n what ur getting away from ur religion are u a true muslim DO U SPEAK arabic do u eat arabic do u dress in a traditional arabian way OR ARE U JUST A CONVERTED DESI MUSLIM
the only thing i want to say is that i can acspect SRK to say this shit cuz i dun consider him as a muslim. what kind of a muslim is he i mean hes having a corner of our holy book and a mandir in the same room, one of his child has a muslim name and other has a hindu name so basically hes a confused guy and if he really said that about the most prestigious person on earth he should be hanged. We muslims our getting away from our religion and its the time that we should realize all of this.
Assalam-u-Alaikum I am a muslim. Me and my friend discussed on this issue and read the line said by SRK. In our opinion this is the Fault of news paper. In fact Shahrukh has praised Hazrat Muhammad(PBUH) and being a Muslim he cannot say any thing about Last Prophet. Holy Prophet Muhammad(The Last Prophet) is our most beloved personality for WE are ready to sacrifice our life.And Same is for every Muslim that each Muslim is ready to sacrifice his life for Hazrat Muhammad(PBUH) including SRK. Regards Ulfat Hussain
aww i love srk, he would neva say that! hes muslim, its the mags misprint!
Its clear he meant the word "negative" to be applied only to Hitler. He put The Prophet between Churchill and Mandela, both of whom, in their different ways, fought for human rights and freedom. Anyone who misconstrues the answer is either confused or intentionally being malicious. SRK's English is very good, but sometimes he could use words more precisely. I'd bet he meant "nice" in the sense of "gentle", which G and MT were.
why would idiots think that he would say that about the Prophet???? He is MUSLIM lol. this is completely ridiculous. lol idk wat to even say
Muslims Condemn action against Shah Rukh Khan http://worldmuslimcongress.blogspot.com/2009/06/muslims-condemn-action-against-shah.html A few Muslims in Mumbai have taken King Khans’ words out of context and have filed a case against him alleging that he maligned the Prophet. (News item below) We the Muslims condemn the acts of the Aman group for initiating such an irresponsible act, and it is time for Muslims to speak out against pettiness like this. It is time for the flaunters to realize that stuff like this happens every day, you 'll find them in every group. The filing of case against Shahrukh Khan by the Aman group deserves condemnation on two counts: i) It is some thing the Prophet would not approve. The Prophet told his followers not to be judgmental about other persons, and if you hear negatives about others, it is your duty to find the truth before it gets out of your mouth. You should not spread falsities and you should not be in a position to regret. ii) It is the dumbest thing and not a Muslim thing to do. One Amit Lal writes: Please note the actual comment made by Shah Rukh before passing judgment. Khan said "According to you who is the most impressive figure in history?" Khan allegedly said, "There are lots of them, some negative ones like Hitler, Napoleon, Winston Churchill and if I can call it history, then Prophet Mohammed and from recent time Nelson Mandela." Here, Hitler is the negative figure, while all the others are the positive figures. The role of a Muslim is to mitigate conflicts and nurture goodwill. Obviously King Khan was misrepresented, and even if he were to be wrong, forgive him, God loves the person who forgives. Fellow Muslims, please speak up. We should discourage all such acts. Forgive this man and move on. Mike Ghouse http://www.worldmuslimcongress.com/
Please stop provoking religious communities for God's sake.
i feel the magazine is at fault too. both quotes are so diff. its amazing how a couple words can change the meaning of statement. yah SRK isnt the model Muslim but I am sure he would never insult the Prophet
How i know Shah Rukh i am sure that he said the second answer he is smart enough not to say so stupid things.I don't know why they made first this article and after they make a statement like this.Again someone who want to damage his positiv image.
Alll i can say is that it was the magazines fault. It looks like they cut off a huge chunk of the article and didn't do a good job at editing. Well, now the controversy has been cleared. Nothing to worry about! When i read the original article from bigoye i was like this magazine is crazy + srk being a muslim, wouldn't degrade the prophet and for that matter, any religious figure!
Yea chill people! I'm sure he's smart enough to know not to say that.. Hello he's SRK for god's sake! I love him! :)
People need to chill about religion!!!
umm obviously the magazine effed up because im sure srk doesnt also think that nelson mandela is a negative figure lol... and plus srk is muslim why would he say that about the prophet lol